Is an online lesson as focused as one at the kitchen table? What the tutor sees, what the parent gets afterwards, and the cases where in person is the better choice, with a side by side table.
In brief
- Online one to one tutoring works as well as in person when the tutor can see the student's working line by line. That is the thing to check, more than the format.
- Online with me is more controlled than a lesson at the kitchen table: one shared screen, every line visible as it is written, corrected on the spot, and nothing else on the desk.
- After each lesson the notes and the whiteboard are saved in the family area, so a parent can see exactly what was done.
- In person is the better choice for some younger students, for families without a tablet or a quiet room, and for hands-on lab work.
Is online tutoring as effective as in-person tutoring?
Online one to one tutoring is as effective as in person when the tutor sees the working as it happens and corrects it on the spot. One to one tuition itself has strong evidence behind it: the Education Endowment Foundation puts it at about five months of additional progress over a year. Direct comparisons of the two formats are fewer, so the honest answer depends on what happens in the lesson, not on where it happens.
In IB Maths and Physics most marks are lost in the working, not in the final answer: a sign dropped in line three, a unit missing, a method mark given away because a step was skipped. A tutor who only sees the final page, online or at the table, misses most of that. A tutor who watches each line being written catches it while it is still cheap to fix.
So the question to ask any tutor, online or in person, is the same: how do you see my child's working while they are doing it?
Online vs in-person tutoring, side by side
I teach mostly online and occasionally in person in Europe, so both columns come from my own lessons. The table compares an online lesson with a typical lesson at home. The last three rows favour in person, and they stay in the table on purpose: they are the cases where I tell families that online may not be the right fit.
| Online | In person at home | |
|---|---|---|
| Seeing the working | Every line on the shared whiteboard as it is written | The notebook, when the tutor leans over it |
| Focus | One screen, a fixed 50-minute structure, nothing else on the desk | Depends on the room and on who else is at home |
| After the lesson | Whiteboard and notes saved in the family area | Depends on the tutor; often the notebook only |
| Choice of tutor | Any tutor, in any country | Whoever can travel to you |
| Time | No travel; the lesson can start right after school | Tutor travel, fewer free slots |
| What it needs | A tablet with a pen, a stable connection, a quiet room | Paper and a table |
| Younger students (Grade 6 to 7) | The first lessons go better with a parent nearby | A person in the room helps some children settle |
| Hands-on lab work | Not possible; experiments stay at school | Possible, with simple equipment |
Is a student more focused online or at the kitchen table?
Online with me is more controlled than a lesson at the kitchen table. There is one shared screen: the student writes on a tablet, I see every line as it is written, and I correct it on the spot. Nothing else is on the table.
At home, a lesson shares the space with everything else: a phone face down next to the notebook, a sibling passing through, the tutor reading the page upside down. None of that is a disaster, but each one takes a little attention away.
Online, the lesson has a fixed shape. Fifty minutes, the camera on, the whiteboard full screen, a problem on the board from the first minute. When attention drops it shows straight away, in the pen stopping or the working slowing down, and I change the task before the lesson is lost. A student who drifts online drifts on a screen I am watching.
What does the tutor see during an online lesson?
During an online lesson I see the student's working on a shared whiteboard, line by line, as it is written. We write on the same page: I can circle a step, add a hint in the margin, or write the next line of a worked example right under theirs.
This is closer than sitting side by side. At a table the tutor sees the notebook at an angle and often only after a line is finished. On the shared board I see the hesitation before the line, the step that was rubbed out, and the moment a method changes halfway. Those are the moments where the diagnosis is.
What does a parent get after each lesson?
After each lesson the notes and the whiteboard are in the family area, so a parent can see exactly what we did. The area also keeps the plan, the work set for the week, the timed papers and how the grade is moving.
With most in-person tutoring the record of a lesson is the student's notebook and the parent's impression from the doorway. Online, everything written in the lesson already exists as a file, so keeping it costs nothing and nothing gets lost between lessons.
When is in-person tutoring the better choice?
In-person tutoring is the better choice for some younger students who find it hard to settle in front of a screen, for families without a tablet or a quiet room, and for hands-on lab work. In these cases I say so in the first conversation.
With Grade 6 and 7 students the first lessons usually go better with a parent nearby, at least for the first few weeks. Without a tablet and pen the shared whiteboard loses most of its value, and a webcam pointed at a notebook is a poor substitute. And no online lesson replaces doing an experiment: the practical side of IB Physics stays at school, while the Internal Assessment report itself works well online.
What does a student need for online lessons?
A student needs a tablet with a pen, a stable internet connection and a quiet room with a desk. A laptop helps for the video call, with the tablet used as the writing surface, but a tablet alone is enough.
The lessons run on Google Meet with the shared whiteboard open, and each one lasts 50 minutes. Nothing has to be installed beyond a browser.
The format matters less than one question: does the tutor see the working while it is being written?
Frequently Asked Questions
Do you also teach in person?▾
Occasionally, in Europe. Most of my lessons are online, on Google Meet. Families in Singapore, Hong Kong, the Gulf and Australia have their lessons online, in their own afternoon or evening.
Is online tutoring as focused as in-person tutoring?▾
With a shared whiteboard, usually more. The student writes on a tablet, the tutor sees every line as it is written and corrects it on the spot, and the lesson has a fixed 50-minute structure with nothing else on the desk.
Can a Grade 6 student have online lessons?▾
Yes, and the first few lessons go better with a parent nearby. If online does not suit a younger student, I say so early.
Can the IB Physics Internal Assessment be done with an online tutor?▾
Yes for the research question, the design, the data analysis and the write-up. The experiment itself is done at school, under the supervision of the student's teacher, as the IB requires.
Sources
Related Articles
Subjects and Specialisations
First session
Find out what is costing the marks.
One to one, online, on Google Meet.