IB Physics A.5 Relativity (HL): why muons reach the ground, time dilation and length contraction
About 21% (2⁻²·² ≈ 0.21, roughly 1 in 5) of the muons reach the ground; classically it would be 2×10⁻⁷.
The question
Muons are created 10 km above the ground and travel vertically downwards at . In the muon's own frame their half-life is 1.5 μs.
(a) Show that, ignoring relativistic effects, a muon travels less than 0.5 km in one half-life. (2 marks)
(b) Determine the fraction of the muons that reach the ground. (4 marks)
The solution
- 01Part (a) is bookwork: distance is speed times time, using the half-life exactly as given. , which is less than half a kilometre.
- 02For part (b), choose the frame in which the clock you were given is the proper one. The half-life is measured in the muon's frame, so work in the muon's frame, where the atmosphere moves past at .
- 03Find the Lorentz factor, keeping all the digits, because at early rounding ruins the answer: .
- 04In the muon's frame the atmosphere is length contracted: .
- 05The time to cross it in the muon's frame is . Dividing by the half-life gives the number of half-lives (not seconds): .
- 06The surviving fraction is one half to the power of : , about 1 muon in 5.
- 07Check from the ground frame, with no contraction: . The muon's clock is dilated, so , and , the same as in the muon frame.
- 08Without relativity the journey lasts 33 μs, which is 22 half-lives, so the fraction would be , about 1 in 5 million against 1 in 5. That is six orders of magnitude, which is why this experiment is quoted as proof.
- 09Pick the frame that owns the proper time and stay in it. Never put a dilated time and a contracted length in the same line, because that counts the effect twice. Keep the digits at , because is very sensitive to rounding.
Answer
About 21% (2⁻²·² ≈ 0.21, roughly 1 in 5) of the muons reach the ground; classically it would be 2×10⁻⁷.
First session
Find out what is costing the marks.
One to one, online, on Google Meet.