Video lessonsIB Physics

IB Physics A.5 Relativity (HL): why muons reach the ground, time dilation and length contraction

About 21% (2⁻²·² ≈ 0.21, roughly 1 in 5) of the muons reach the ground; classically it would be 2×10⁻⁷.

View on YouTube

The question

Muons are created 10 km above the ground and travel vertically downwards at v=0.995cv = 0.995c. In the muon's own frame their half-life is 1.5 μs.

(a) Show that, ignoring relativistic effects, a muon travels less than 0.5 km in one half-life. (2 marks)

(b) Determine the fraction of the muons that reach the ground. (4 marks)

The solution

  1. 01Part (a) is bookwork: distance is speed times time, using the half-life exactly as given. d=v t1/2=0.995c×1.5×10−6 s≈4.5×102 m=0.45 kmd = v\,t_{1/2} = 0.995c \times 1.5\times 10^{-6}\ \text{s} \approx 4.5\times 10^{2}\ \text{m} = 0.45\ \text{km}, which is less than half a kilometre.
  2. 02For part (b), choose the frame in which the clock you were given is the proper one. The half-life is measured in the muon's frame, so work in the muon's frame, where the atmosphere moves past at 0.995c0.995c.
  3. 03Find the Lorentz factor, keeping all the digits, because at 0.995c0.995c early rounding ruins the answer: γ=11−0.9952=10.0\gamma = \frac{1}{\sqrt{1-0.995^{2}}} = 10.0.
  4. 04In the muon's frame the atmosphere is length contracted: L=L0γ=10 km10.0≈1.0 kmL = \frac{L_0}{\gamma} = \frac{10\ \text{km}}{10.0} \approx 1.0\ \text{km}.
  5. 05The time to cross it in the muon's frame is t=Lv≈3.3 μst = \frac{L}{v} \approx 3.3\ \mu\text{s}. Dividing by the half-life gives the number of half-lives (not seconds): n=3.31.5≈2.2n = \frac{3.3}{1.5} \approx 2.2.
  6. 06The surviving fraction is one half to the power of nn: N/N0=2−2.2≈0.21N/N_0 = 2^{-2.2} \approx 0.21, about 1 muon in 5.
  7. 07Check from the ground frame, with no contraction: t=L0v=1040.995c≈33 μst = \frac{L_0}{v} = \frac{10^{4}}{0.995c} \approx 33\ \mu\text{s}. The muon's clock is dilated, so t1/2=γ t1/2,0=10.0×1.5=15 μst_{1/2} = \gamma\,t_{1/2,0} = 10.0 \times 1.5 = 15\ \mu\text{s}, and n=3315≈2.2n = \frac{33}{15} \approx 2.2, the same as in the muon frame.
  8. 08Without relativity the journey lasts 33 μs, which is 22 half-lives, so the fraction would be 2−22≈2×10−72^{-22} \approx 2\times 10^{-7}, about 1 in 5 million against 1 in 5. That is six orders of magnitude, which is why this experiment is quoted as proof.
  9. 09Pick the frame that owns the proper time and stay in it. Never put a dilated time and a contracted length in the same line, because that counts the effect twice. Keep the digits at 0.995c0.995c, because γ\gamma is very sensitive to rounding.

Answer
About 21% (2⁻²·² ≈ 0.21, roughly 1 in 5) of the muons reach the ground; classically it would be 2×10⁻⁷.

← IB worked solutions, on video

Find out what is costing the marks.

One to one, online, on Google Meet.

Book a first session