Criteria referred to in each idea: A Presentation, B Mathematical communication, C Personal engagement, D Reflection, E Use of mathematics.
Topic 5, calculus: 33 ideas
Reproduction number and peak of an SIR epidemic
Aim. How does the peak proportion infected in an SIR model depend on the reproduction number, and how well does a fitted model reproduce a real outbreak?
- AA and AI · HL topic
- Needs care
- Public data
- Seen too often in subject reports
- Overdone: on 6 sites
My take. Extremely overdone: listed on six public lists and named in the subject reports among topics seen too often. Only choose this narrow version, with the analytic peak and a critical fitting exercise on an outbreak you have a reason to study.
Mathematics, first steps and where marks are lost+
- Mathematics
- Coupled differential equations, separation of variables after dividing dI/dt by dS/dt, integration, logarithms, Euler's method with step-size refinement, finding the maximum where dI/dt = 0. Beyond syllabus: least-squares fitting of the two rates.
- How to start
- Download daily case counts of a school flu outbreak or a national epidemic from a health agency. Write the SIR equations, find the exact peak formula analytically, and compare with an Euler solution.
- SL and HL
- Differential equations are HL in both courses. HL depth: eliminate time analytically, derive Imax = 1 − (1 + ln R₀)/R₀ for a fully susceptible start, and compare it with an Euler solution and with real data. An SL student would be outside the course.
- Where marks are lost
- E: only running a solver with no derivation. C: generic COVID topic with no personal angle. B: unexplained assumptions such as constant population. D: no discussion of the model's limits.
- Data
- Data are easy to find but noisy, and reported cases rarely match the infected compartment.
Cooling of a hot drink: does one exponential fit?
Aim. How well does a decaying exponential with a fixed room-temperature asymptote describe a cooling mug of tea, and does the fitted rate constant stay the same as the drink cools?
- AA and AI · SL and HL
- Easy to start
- Your own data
- Seen too often in subject reports
- Overdone: on 4 sites
My take. Newton's law of cooling is named in the subject reports among topics seen too often, so it only scores with a personal twist, such as comparing the mug you actually use with a flask, and an analysis of the pattern in the residuals rather than praise for the fit.
Mathematics, first steps and where marks are lost+
- Mathematics
- Exponential model T = Ta + (T0 − Ta)e−kt; linearising by taking ln(T − Ta) against t; least-squares regression; residual plots; percentage error. HL: separable differential equation dT/dt = −k(T − Ta) solved analytically. Beyond syllabus: compare with a two-term exponential to capture early rapid loss.
- How to start
- Pour boiling water into one mug, log temperature every 30 seconds for 40 minutes with a digital thermometer, and record room temperature at the start and end. Compute ln(T − Ta) for each reading and check whether the points lie on a line.
- SL and HL
- SL fits the exponential and linearised forms and judges them by residuals and R². HL derives the model from the differential equation and tests whether k drifts with temperature, which is where real insight appears.
- Where marks are lost
- C: a copy of a common topic with no personal twist. E: only fitting a formula without testing its assumptions. D: reporting a good R² without asking why residuals show a pattern. A: too many raw data tables.
- Data
- Data is easy to collect, but the room temperature must be logged and the sensor error stated.
Why drinks cans are not the minimum surface area cylinder
Aim. For a can of fixed volume 330 ml, what dimensions minimise metal, and how must the cost model change to explain the shape of real cans?
- AA and AI · SL and HL
- Easy to start
- Your own data
- Seen too often in subject reports
- Overdone: on 4 sites
My take. Minimising the surface of a can is named in the subject reports among topics seen too often. It is only worth choosing with measured cans and a clearly justified cost model, which lifts it above a textbook problem.
Mathematics, first steps and where marks are lost+
- Mathematics
- Volume and surface area of a cylinder, elimination of a variable by substitution, differentiation of S = 2πr² + 2V/r, second derivative test, then a weighted cost function with a thicker material in the lid and base and rim allowance. Beyond syllabus: Lagrange multipliers to confirm the result, or comparison with other prisms.
- How to start
- Measure the height, diameter and wall thickness of five different real cans, then work out the ideal ratio h : r for pure surface area and compute how far each can deviates.
- SL and HL
- SL optimises the plain and weighted cost functions with the derivative and compares with measured cans. HL adds sensitivity analysis on the cost weights, a numerical or implicit approach, and a comparison with a spherical or hexagonal packing constraint.
- Where marks are lost
- E: the simple h = 2r result is a textbook exercise, so marks depend on the extension. C: no personal measurements. D: no sensible reasons why real cans deviate, such as stacking and grip.
- Data
- Real cans are easy to measure, and the extension is a modelling choice.
Football flight with quadratic drag solved numerically
Aim. How far does a kicked football fall short of the vacuum range when quadratic drag is included, and what launch angle maximises range?
- AA and AI · HL topic
- Needs care
- Your own data
- Seen too often in subject reports
- Common: on 3 sites
My take. Projectiles in sport are named in the subject reports among topics seen too often, and three public lists carry this one. It only works with your own tracked data and a clear comparison of two drag laws.
Mathematics, first steps and where marks are lost+
- Mathematics
- Set up the coupled equations for horizontal and vertical velocity with a drag term proportional to speed squared. Solve using Euler's method, then improve with a second-order scheme such as Heun's. Compare with the linear-drag case, which has an exact solution by separation of variables. Estimate the optimal angle numerically. Check against measured range from video or published data. Beyond syllabus: non-dimensionalise the system.
- How to start
- Film a ball being kicked or thrown against a gridded background and extract positions with tracking software such as Tracker. Then code the drag model in a spreadsheet and fit the drag coefficient.
- SL and HL
- Differential equations and Euler's method are HL in both courses. HL depth comes from the coupled equations, the exact linear-drag solution as a check, step-size error analysis and the optimal-angle search.
- Where marks are lost
- E: using a spreadsheet without justifying the step size. C: choosing a textbook example with no personal data. B: not explaining why drag is modelled as proportional to v squared. D: no discussion of spin or wind.
- Data
- Video tracking is achievable, but fitting the drag coefficient reliably needs several throws and careful scaling.
Lotka-Volterra cycles fitted to lynx and hare pelts
Aim. How closely does a Lotka-Volterra system, with parameters fitted to the Hudson Bay lynx and hare records, reproduce the observed cycle length, and where does it fail?
- AA and AI · HL topic
- Easy to start
- Public data
- Common: on 3 sites
My take. Popular and easily done badly, so choose it only if you commit to fitting real data and criticising the model. The twist is testing why the real cycle is not the neat closed orbit the equations promise.
Mathematics, first steps and where marks are lost+
- Mathematics
- Coupled first-order differential equations, equilibrium points, phase portraits, numerical solution by Euler's method, the conserved quantity that makes the orbits closed. AI HL students can use eigenvalues for the linearised system. Beyond syllabus: linearisation with the Jacobian matrix, and adding a logistic limit on prey so that the closed orbits become a spiral.
- How to start
- Download the Hudson Bay Company lynx and hare pelt counts (about 90 years, publicly available in R datasets and many university pages). Plot both series, measure the average period, then estimate the four parameters from the equilibrium values and the period before coding Euler in a spreadsheet.
- SL and HL
- An SL student can do a single-species version and a step-by-step simulation of the pair, comparing the cycle with the data graphically, though this sits outside the SL course. HL depth comes from the equilibria, the conserved quantity, the stability of the equilibrium, and a comparison of the pure model with the logistic-prey version.
- Where marks are lost
- E: stopping at 'the graph looks cyclic' with no analysis of equilibrium or stability. B: pasting solver output without explaining the steps. C: generic ecology with no personal link. D: no comment on the pelt counts being a proxy for true populations.
- Data
- The pelt data is public and clean, but choosing a fitting method for four parameters needs care.
Catenoid versus two discs: soap film area
Aim. For two coaxial rings at a given distance apart, when does a catenoid film have less area than two flat discs, and at what separation does the catenoid cease to exist?
- AA and AI · HL topic
- Needs care
- Your own data
- Common: on 2 sites
My take. Strong if the experiment is real and the catenary is derived. The broad 'soap bubble minimal surface' framing is weak, so use this narrow question.
Mathematics, first steps and where marks are lost+
- Mathematics
- Surface area of revolution by integration (beyond the syllabus), the catenary y = a cosh(x/a) written with exponentials, solving a transcendental equation numerically, comparing areas. Beyond syllabus: the Euler-Lagrange equation to derive the catenary.
- How to start
- Dip two wire rings of equal radius into soap solution, pull them apart and record the ring separation when the film snaps. Then compute the theoretical catenoid area for each separation.
- SL and HL
- Best at HL. Take the catenary as given, integrate to get the area and compare with the discs numerically; find the separation where the discs win (about 1.06 times the radius) and where the catenoid stops existing (about 1.33 times the radius), and compare with your measurements.
- Where marks are lost
- E: the variational derivation is only quoted. C: no real experiment. D: failing to explain why measured and predicted breaking distances differ. A: too many pages on the physics.
- Data
- Measurements are simple but noisy; the critical ratio needs numerical solving of cosh equations.
Fitting logistic growth to census data and predicting a limit
Aim. How reliable is the carrying capacity predicted by a logistic model fitted to census data up to a chosen year, compared with later observed values?
- AA and AI · SL and HL
- Easy to start
- Public data
- Common: on 2 sites
My take. A sound choice if you test predictions using old data against what really happened. The twist is showing how unstable K is when estimated early on.
Mathematics, first steps and where marks are lost+
- Mathematics
- Logistic differential equation dP/dt = rP(1 - P/K), solution by separation of variables and partial fractions, the point of inflexion at P = K/2, nonlinear regression or linearisation, comparison of predictions from different cut-off years. Beyond syllabus but reachable: adding a delay or an Allee effect.
- How to start
- Download census populations for one country, such as the USA from 1790 or a smaller region, and fit a logistic curve using only data before 1900. Compare the predicted curve and K with what happened afterwards.
- SL and HL
- SL students can use the logistic function form, fit it with technology and compare to an exponential model. HL students can derive the solution, prove the inflexion at K/2, and study how the estimate of K moves as more years are included.
- Where marks are lost
- E: using regression software as a black box with no derivation. D: not admitting that the fit is poor for demographic data. B: unexplained parameter values. A: too many similar graphs.
- Data
- Census data is easy to obtain; the tricky part is choosing a fitting method and explaining it.
Half-life from a differential equation and real decay counts
Aim. How well does the exponential decay law, derived from the assumption that decay rate is proportional to the number of nuclei, fit counts from a real decaying source, and how large is the error in the estimated half-life?
- AA and AI · SL and HL
- Needs care
- Your own data
- Common: on 2 sites
My take. Very common and close to a textbook exercise unless real data and uncertainty are the focus. The twist is comparing a physical decay with a dice model and asking which is closer to the law.
Mathematics, first steps and where marks are lost+
- Mathematics
- Separable differential equation dN/dt = -kN and its solution, half-life as ln2/k, natural logarithms to linearise data, least-squares regression on ln(count), residual analysis. Beyond syllabus but reachable: Poisson noise in counts and the resulting uncertainty in k.
- How to start
- Use a public dataset of Geiger counter readings for a short-lived isotope such as barium-137m, or the well-known dice or coin decay simulation with 200 dice. Take ln of the counts, fit a line and get k and its uncertainty.
- SL and HL
- SL students can use the exponential model, logarithmic linearisation and regression, and compare with the dice simulation. HL students can solve the differential equation by separation, add background radiation as a constant term, and treat the random scatter with a Poisson argument.
- Where marks are lost
- E: quoting N = N0 e-kt without deriving it or testing it. A: a very short exploration that repeats standard textbook working. C: no reason given for the choice. D: no evaluation of the fit or of background counts.
- Data
- Real counts need a source or a public dataset; a dice simulation is an easy backup but is less authentic.
Measuring inequality: Gini by Lorenz curve integration
Aim. How much do trapezium-rule and fitted-function integration of the Lorenz curve differ in the Gini coefficient for national income data, and which is more reliable?
- AA and AI · SL and HL
- Easy to start
- Public data
- Common: on 2 sites
My take. Good if you focus on comparing numerical methods and their error, not describing inequality. Choose countries or years you have a reason to care about.
Mathematics, first steps and where marks are lost+
- Mathematics
- Definition Gini = 1 − 2∫L(x)dx; trapezium rule on grouped quintile or decile data; fitting a function such as L(x) = xp and integrating it exactly; error comparison between methods; comparing countries or years. HL: an integration of the fitted function and a discussion of the relationship to the mean absolute difference.
- How to start
- Download income share by decile for two countries from the World Bank. Build the Lorenz points, compute the Gini with the trapezium rule, then fit L(x) = xp and integrate it, and compare the two values with the published one.
- SL and HL
- SL uses the trapezium rule and exact integration of a fitted power function, for which the Gini is (p − 1)/(p + 1). HL adds a richer fitted family and compares the integral formula with the mean absolute difference definition.
- Where marks are lost
- E: plugging numbers into a formula with no comparison of methods. C: a generic choice of countries. D: no note that grouped data underestimates inequality inside each group. B: the Lorenz curve not defined properly.
- Data
- Decile data is publicly available and clean, so the challenge is in the analysis.
Straight ramp or cycloid: timing the descent
Aim. By what percentage is the descent time along a cycloid shorter than along a straight line joining the same two points, and can a physical track confirm it?
- AA · HL topic
- Needs care
- Your own data
- Common: on 2 sites
My take. Attractive and rich, and a track experiment makes it personal. Do not attempt to prove optimality; keep to comparing paths.
Mathematics, first steps and where marks are lost+
- Mathematics
- Energy conservation v = √(2gy), time as ∫ ds/v with ds from parametric derivatives, cycloid x = a(t − sin t), y = a(1 − cos t), a substitution to evaluate exactly, numerical integration for the straight line and other paths (parabola, circle arc), percentage comparison. Beyond syllabus: an outline of why the Euler-Lagrange equation leads to the cycloid, quoted rather than proved.
- How to start
- Choose two points, write the descent time integral for a straight line and evaluate it, then do the cycloid; afterwards build two tracks and time a ball with slow-motion video.
- SL and HL
- The time integral along a curve is beyond both syllabi, so this suits a confident HL student; a strong SL student could time straight and polygonal paths with numerical sums only. Top marks come from comparing several families of paths and reconciling rolling friction with the model.
- Where marks are lost
- E: claiming the calculus of variations without understanding it, so quote it honestly. B: parametric notation. D: ignoring that a rolling ball has rotational energy, which changes constants.
- Data
- Mathematics is clean; the physical test needs careful timing and a correction for rolling.
Where to sit in a cinema for the widest view
Aim. At what distance from the screen is the vertical angle subtended by the screen largest, and how does this compare with where people actually choose or are advised to sit?
- AA and AI · SL and HL
- Easy to start
- Your own data
- Common: on 2 sites
My take. Weak alone because it is a known textbook problem; make it worthwhile by modelling a real cinema with a raked floor and comparing with a small survey of favourite rows.
Mathematics, first steps and where marks are lost+
- Mathematics
- Angle as a difference of two arctangents, θ = arctan((h+b)/x) − arctan(b/x), differentiation of arctan, solving dθ/dx = 0 to give x = √(b(b+h)), second-derivative or sign test, alternative proof by the tangent subtraction formula, sensitivity to h and b. Beyond syllabus: a sloping floor with rake, so that the eye height changes with distance.
- How to start
- Measure or find plans for a real auditorium: screen height, height of its lower edge above eye level. Derive the optimum symbolically first, then check it numerically with a graph.
- SL and HL
- SL can do the tangent-difference and a graphical or numerical maximum with a derivative. HL handles arctan derivatives directly, does the general result in b and h, and adds the sloping floor.
- Where marks are lost
- E: this is very close to a textbook optimisation, so it needs the extension (rake, horizontal angle, a survey). C: generic wording with no personal source. B: not defining eye height clearly.
- Data
- Only a few measurements are needed; a survey of seat preferences would add data but is optional.
Best cone from a fixed sheet of paper
Aim. Which cone has the greatest volume when it is made from a sector of a circular sheet of fixed radius, and does the answer change when the area of paper is fixed instead?
- AA and AI · SL and HL
- Easy to start
- Your own data
- Rarely listed
My take. A decent optimisation idea when the experiment is real. Fairly standard otherwise, so the physical comparison is what makes it yours.
Mathematics, first steps and where marks are lost+
- Mathematics
- Curved surface area πrl, l = √(r² + h²), eliminating a variable, differentiation of a volume function involving a square root, second derivative test, sector angle and arc length. With a fixed slant height (a sheet of fixed radius) the best sector angle is 2π√(2/3), about 294°; with a fixed area of paper it is 2π/√3, about 208°.
- How to start
- Cut sectors of several angles from a disc of card of radius 15 cm, form the cones, and measure their volumes with rice. Then write V as a function of r with l fixed, find the maximum, and compare.
- SL and HL
- SL derives both optima and checks them with paper cones. HL proves the optimum angles do not depend on the size of the sheet, and analyses the experimental error from overlap and seams.
- Where marks are lost
- E: stopping at one calculus problem. D: no explanation of why real cups differ. A: messy geometry diagrams.
- Data
- Easy to model and to test with simple materials.
Best throwing angle from a raised release point
Aim. How does the launch angle that gives the greatest range change as the release height above the landing level increases, and does it tend to 45° only when that height is zero?
- AA and AI · SL and HL
- Easy to start
- Your own data
- Seen too often in subject reports
- Rarely listed
My take. Projectiles in sport are named in the subject reports among topics seen too often, but the closed form for the best angle is demanding and tractable. Using release data from your own sport gives it a strong personal angle.
Mathematics, first steps and where marks are lost+
- Mathematics
- Parametric equations x = u cos θ · t, y = h + u sin θ · t − ½gt², solving a quadratic for flight time, range R(θ), implicit differentiation, trigonometric identities. HL: deriving tan θ = u / √(u² + 2gh), limiting behaviour as h → 0 and h → ∞.
- How to start
- Derive R(θ) for h = 0 and confirm 45°. Then include h, use a graph to find the optimal angle numerically for several h, and compare with a video analysis of a ball thrown from a balcony or a shot put.
- SL and HL
- SL computes the optimum numerically for chosen heights and plots it. HL derives the closed form for the optimal angle and studies the limits. Top marks come from comparing with real shot put release data and discussing air resistance.
- Where marks are lost
- E: numerical results only, without the general formula. B: long algebra with no signposting. D: ignoring air resistance and human release limits.
- Data
- Mainly theory, with optional video tracking data that is easy to collect.
Fastest route across sand and sea
Aim. How does the fastest crossing point on a straight beach change as the ratio of running speed to swimming speed varies, and how well does the calculus model match timed trials on a real beach or playing field?
- AA and AI · SL and HL
- Easy to start
- Your own data
- Rarely listed
My take. A classic and safe choice, but well known, so it only scores well if you gather your own speeds and go beyond one solved case. Set it on a course you really use, such as your school field and a sandy area, and study how the optimum moves with the speed ratio.
Mathematics, first steps and where marks are lost+
- Mathematics
- Pythagoras to build the total time T(x) = √(a²+x²)/v₂ + √(b²+(d−x)²)/v₁; differentiation of composite functions with the chain rule; solving T′(x)=0 and justifying a minimum with the sign of T′ or the second derivative; sensitivity of the optimum to the speed ratio, using a graphing tool; comparison with the straight-line path and the path that runs as far as possible on the fast surface. HL extension: rewrite the condition as sin θ₁/sin θ₂ = v₁/v₂ and link it to Snell's law. Squaring T′(x) = 0 gives a quartic, which is why a numerical solution is the honest route.
- How to start
- Pick a scenario with two surfaces: for example a grass pitch next to a sandy strip, or a pool edge and water. Time yourself over 20 m on each surface to get v₁ and v₂. Then write T(x) for one fixed start and finish, plot it in Desmos or GeoGebra, and find the minimum before touching any derivative.
- SL and HL
- SL students can complete a sound piece by setting up T(x), differentiating, solving numerically, and testing the model against measured times. HL depth comes from expressing the optimum as an angle condition, proving it is Snell's law, and exploring a family of speed ratios.
- Where marks are lost
- E: stopping at a single worked example, which is a textbook optimisation problem, without generalising over the speed ratio. C: using invented speeds instead of measured ones. D: no discussion of model limits such as acceleration, a swimmer drifting, or wading speed. B: leaving the algebra of the derivative unexplained.
- Data
- The model needs no data, and the optional timing experiment is simple to run with a stopwatch and a measuring tape.
Finding the basketball shot with most room for error
Aim. For a free throw, which release angle allows the widest range of release speeds or angles to still score, and how does this differ from the angle that needs the least speed?
- AA and AI · SL and HL
- Easy to start
- Simulation
- Seen too often in subject reports
- Rarely listed
My take. Projectiles in sport are named in the subject reports among topics seen too often, but the idea that different objectives give different best angles is genuinely interesting. Make it personal by filming your own shots and comparing your angle with the predicted one.
Mathematics, first steps and where marks are lost+
- Mathematics
- Projectile motion written as y = x tanθ − gx²/(2v²cos²θ); ball and rim geometry giving the entry angle condition; differentiation to optimise both minimum speed and tolerance window; sensitivity analysis using partial changes in v and θ. Beyond syllabus: a simple comparison with a no-drag versus linear-drag model, only if numerical work is done in a spreadsheet.
- How to start
- Set the hoop at 3.05 m, release height at about 2.0 m, free-throw distance 4.57 m. Solve for the speed needed at each angle from 40 to 70 degrees, then for each angle find the range of speeds that still lets a ball of 24 cm diameter pass a 45 cm rim. Plot the width of that range against angle.
- SL and HL
- SL: work out the trajectory, find the minimum speed angle by differentiation and compare it with the widest tolerance window found numerically. HL: derive the tolerance width analytically using implicit differentiation, and add air resistance through a differential equation solved by Euler's method.
- Where marks are lost
- E: stopping at one optimum and not justifying why tolerance is a fair objective. B: unclear notation for the two different optimisation problems. D: no comment on ignoring spin and drag. C: generic sports link with no personal shots or video evidence.
- Data
- Everything can be simulated from known heights and distances, though filming a few real shots with a phone would add credibility.
Gabriel's Horn: paint paradox and improper integrals
Aim. Why does rotating y = 1/x for x at least 1 give a solid of finite volume but infinite surface area, and does the paradox survive when the curve is changed to y = 1/xp?
- AA · HL topic
- Easy to start
- Pure maths, no data
- Rarely listed
My take. Very well known, so the plain version is weak. Generalising to 1/xp and finding where the paradox exists makes it your own.
Mathematics, first steps and where marks are lost+
- Mathematics
- Integrals with an infinite upper limit, treated as limits; volume π∫y² dx; surface area 2π∫y√(1 + y′²) dx (beyond the syllabus); comparison by bounding the integrand from below; convergence of ∫ x−p dx. Numerical integration to watch the divergence.
- How to start
- Compute the volume exactly with a limit at b, then bound the surface integrand below by 2 pi/x to prove divergence. Then repeat for general p and find the range where each integral converges.
- SL and HL
- Volumes of revolution are HL, and the surface area integral is beyond the syllabus but needs only a lower bound, so this suits HL. Top marks come from the general p analysis and an honest discussion of what the paradox means physically.
- Where marks are lost
- E: only reproducing the standard argument. B: skipped steps in the divergence bound. C: no personal angle beyond repeating a famous result.
- Data
- Pure theory with clean algebra, but the surface area formula needs careful justification.
How container shape decides the time to drain
Aim. How does the profile of a container determine the time for water to drain through a small hole, and why do real draining times exceed the ideal prediction?
- AA and AI · HL topic
- Needs care
- Your own data
- Rarely listed
My take. Very good for an HL student who likes experiments. The discrepancy with the ideal model is the part that shows real reflection, so plan enough trials.
Mathematics, first steps and where marks are lost+
- Mathematics
- Torricelli's law v = √(2gh); conservation of volume giving A(h) dh/dt = −a√(2gh); separation of variables and integration for cylinder, cone and paraboloid; comparison of predictions with measured times; introduction of a discharge coefficient fitted from data. Beyond syllabus: shaping a container so the water level falls at a constant rate.
- How to start
- Drill a 4 mm hole near the base of a cylindrical bottle, record water height against time on video, and derive the ideal dh/dt. Compare the predicted curve with the data and estimate the correction factor.
- SL and HL
- Separable differential equations are HL, so the main analysis is HL. An SL student could study only the cylinder using a function fit to the data and a simple integral, but with less depth.
- Where marks are lost
- E: solving the equation but not linking to the experiment. D: not explaining the discrepancy in terms of contraction of the jet or viscosity. A: video timing errors ignored. B: units and notation for area not defined.
- Data
- Needs a careful experiment and timing from video, but equipment is cheap.
How many Maclaurin terms are enough?
Aim. How many terms of the Maclaurin series of eˣ, sin x and cos x are needed to stay within 10⁻⁶ of the true value across intervals of increasing width, and why do the functions behave differently?
- AA · HL topic
- Easy to start
- Simulation
- Rarely listed
My take. A solid HL idea, though it can drift into an exercise. The range reduction question, or how a calculator actually computes sin, gives it a personal purpose.
Mathematics, first steps and where marks are lost+
- Mathematics
- Maclaurin series of eˣ, sin x, cos x; partial sums and error against the true function; Lagrange remainder or alternating series error bound; comparison of bound with actual error; growth of the required n with interval half-width. Beyond syllabus: range reduction as used in calculators.
- How to start
- Write partial sums in a spreadsheet or Python for x in [−1,1], then [−3,3] and [−10,10]. For each, find the smallest n that keeps the maximum error below 10⁻⁶ and plot n against the interval width.
- SL and HL
- Maclaurin series are HL only, so this is an HL idea. It gains depth by proving the remainder bound and asking how a calculator can avoid huge n by using periodicity.
- Where marks are lost
- E: numerical results without proving the bound. A: repetitive tables for each function. D: not asking why the bound overestimates. C: no motivation beyond a textbook exercise.
- Data
- Pure theory with easy computation, but the remainder proof needs to be explained carefully.
How quickly numerical integration closes in on π
Aim. How does the error in estimating π from the area under 4/(1+x²) fall with the number of intervals for left, midpoint, trapezium and Simpson's rules?
- AA and AI · SL and HL
- Easy to start
- Simulation
- Rarely listed
My take. Solid and safe, but common in spirit, so the log-log analysis and theoretical prediction must carry the work. A twist is to compare with a series method for π, such as Machin-type arctan formulas.
Mathematics, first steps and where marks are lost+
- Mathematics
- Definite integral ∫₀¹ 4/(1+x²) dx = π; left Riemann sums, midpoint and trapezium rules; log-log plots of error against n to estimate the order of convergence. HL: the error of one trapezium strip from a Taylor expansion. Beyond syllabus: Simpson's rule and its error term.
- How to start
- In a spreadsheet or Python, compute each rule for n = 2, 4, 8, ... 1024. Record |estimate − π| and plot log(error) against log(n) to read off the gradient for each method.
- SL and HL
- SL: implement the rules, find the gradients experimentally and explain them using the shape of the curve. HL: derive the h² error of the trapezium and midpoint rules from Taylor expansions over one strip, compare with the observed gradients, and explain why the midpoint error is about half the trapezium error with opposite sign.
- Where marks are lost
- E: pages of tables with no explanation of why the gradients appear. A: too many similar tables. D: no comparison between measured and predicted convergence rates. C: little personal angle unless the student links to how calculators find π.
- Data
- Pure computation, no data collection, though care is needed with floating point rounding for very large n.
How the step size governs Euler's method error
Aim. How does the global error of Euler's method depend on the step size h, and can the proportionality be explained using Taylor's theorem?
- AA and AI · HL topic
- Easy to start
- Simulation
- Rarely listed
My take. A good, honest numerical exploration. The extra step of a second order method and a case where the exact solution is unknown makes it personal.
Mathematics, first steps and where marks are lost+
- Mathematics
- Euler's method; comparison with exact solutions of dy/dx = y and dy/dx = x + y; Taylor expansion to identify local error of order h²; accumulation to global error of order h; log-log plot of error against h. Beyond syllabus: the improved Euler or midpoint method.
- How to start
- Code Euler in a spreadsheet for dy/dx = y with y(0) = 1, using h = 0.5, 0.25, 0.125, and so on. Compute the error at x = 1 against e.
- SL and HL
- Euler's method is HL content. Depth comes from the Taylor argument and from comparing with a second order method to show the changed scaling.
- Where marks are lost
- E: observing that halving h halves error without explaining it. B: undefined local and global error. D: no discussion of rounding error at very small h.
- Data
- Exact solutions exist to test against, so the numerical data is clean.
Minimising cost of a pipe or cable route
Aim. What is the cheapest route for a cable or pipe across ground of two different costs per metre, and how sensitive is the optimum to changes in those costs?
- AA and AI · SL and HL
- Easy to start
- Pure maths, no data
- Rarely listed
My take. Workable but close to a stock exercise unless you make the sensitivity analysis the core. Use real quoted prices for a local project to make it yours.
Mathematics, first steps and where marks are lost+
- Mathematics
- Building a cost function with Pythagoras, differentiation, stationary points and second derivative test, constraint handling, sensitivity analysis by varying a parameter, graph checks. Beyond syllabus: Lagrange multipliers for a constrained version.
- How to start
- Take a real situation such as a cable from a house to a point across a river with different costs on land and in water. Sketch it, define the variable, write cost as a function and graph it before differentiating.
- SL and HL
- SL can work with a single variable cost function, GDC graphing and a table for the minimum. HL treats it fully with derivatives, implicit relations or a family of cost ratios and a general formula for the optimum.
- Where marks are lost
- E: an optimisation problem that is exactly a textbook one. C: invented numbers with no source. D: no sensitivity or realism check, for example ignoring that real routes cannot be perfectly straight.
- Data
- Pure theory with real costs looked up, so data are simple and the maths is well controlled.
Newton-Raphson against bisection: convergence speed compared
Aim. How many iterations do bisection and Newton-Raphson need to reach a given accuracy for different functions, and when does Newton-Raphson fail?
- AA and AI · SL and HL
- Easy to start
- Simulation
- Rarely listed
My take. A solid, answerable exploration when it is a comparison of two algorithms with measured and predicted convergence. Make it yours with an equation you met elsewhere, such as in a physics problem.
Mathematics, first steps and where marks are lost+
- Mathematics
- Differentiation, tangent lines, iteration and fixed points, error analysis, sign change and the intermediate value idea, order of convergence from log of error. HL extension: Taylor series argument for quadratic convergence and analysis of failures near a zero derivative.
- How to start
- Code both methods in Python for f(x) = x³ - 2 and cos x - x. Record the error after each step and plot log(error) against iteration number.
- SL and HL
- SL students can compare the methods on several functions and explain results using tangent geometry. HL students can prove quadratic convergence with Taylor expansion and study cycles or divergence for awkward starting values.
- Where marks are lost
- E: presenting code as the maths. B: undefined error terms. D: no discussion of when each method is preferable.
- Data
- Simulation is quick and reproducible; rigour lies in the error analysis.
Optimal pricing for a small business using a fitted demand curve
Aim. What price maximises weekly profit for a school-run product such as cakes or badges, and how sensitive is that price to the demand model chosen?
- AA and AI · SL and HL
- Needs care
- Your own data
- Rarely listed
My take. With real prices and a comparison of demand models it is decent, and a genuine venture of your own, such as a school club stall, is what lifts it.
Mathematics, first steps and where marks are lost+
- Mathematics
- Linear and exponential regression for demand, revenue and profit functions, differentiation to find stationary points, second derivative test, price elasticity of demand, sensitivity analysis on the model's parameters. Beyond syllabus: compare with Lagrange-type constraints when stock is limited.
- How to start
- Sell one item at four or five different prices over several days or run a survey of stated willingness to pay. Fit linear and exponential demand models and write the profit function for each.
- SL and HL
- SL fits a linear demand and optimises profit with the derivative. HL compares model families, uses price elasticity, or adds a capacity constraint.
- Where marks are lost
- E: a single quadratic profit function is a textbook exercise. C: generic business setting. D: model never questioned. A: too many tables.
- Data
- Real sales data is small and noisy, so honesty about uncertainty is needed.
Period doubling and chaos in the logistic map
Aim. At which parameter values does the logistic map x(n+1) = r x(n)(1 - x(n)) change its long-term behaviour, and how fast do these changes accumulate towards chaos?
- AA and AI · SL and HL
- Easy to start
- Simulation
- Rarely listed
My take. Well known but still good if the algebra is done properly. Narrowing to one map, with a derived first bifurcation and a measured Lyapunov exponent, makes it a real investigation.
Mathematics, first steps and where marks are lost+
- Mathematics
- Iterated functions and recurrence relations; fixed points found by solving f(x) = x; stability from the sign and size of |f'(x)| at the fixed point; period-two points by solving f(f(x)) = x; bifurcation diagram from spreadsheet or Python iteration; estimating the Lyapunov exponent as the mean of ln|f'(xn)|. Beyond syllabus but reachable: Feigenbaum's constant from successive bifurcation values.
- How to start
- Iterate the map in a spreadsheet for r = 2.8, 3.2, 3.5 and 3.9 from two starting values that differ by 0.001. Then derive the fixed points and the condition |f'| < 1 by hand and compare with what the iteration shows.
- SL and HL
- SL students can do the fixed point and derivative stability analysis and a simulated diagram. HL adds the algebra of the period-two cycle, the Lyapunov exponent as an average of logarithms and the ratio of successive bifurcation gaps.
- Where marks are lost
- E: relying on plots with no analytic derivation of the first bifurcation at r = 3. A: too many similar diagrams. D: no comment on floating point error limiting the chaotic results.
- Data
- Data is generated by iteration and the analysis is algebraic, so the only care needed is with rounding in long runs.
Sine waves that add up to a square wave
Aim. How does the error in a partial Fourier sum of a square wave fall as more harmonics are added, and why does an overshoot remain near the jump?
- AA · HL topic
- Needs care
- Simulation
- Rarely listed
My take. Impressive if the integrals are done properly and the overshoot is measured. Twist: link to audio synthesis by playing the partial sums.
Mathematics, first steps and where marks are lost+
- Mathematics
- Integration by parts; integrals of products of sines and cosines over a period (orthogonality); Fourier coefficients bₙ = 4/(nπ) for odd n; partial sums; mean-square error; maximum of the overshoot from the first turning point. Beyond syllabus: Gibbs constant ≈ 1.179 via the sine integral.
- How to start
- Derive the coefficients by integration. Then plot partial sums with 1, 3, 5, 15 terms in Desmos or Python and record the mean-square error and the peak height near the jump.
- SL and HL
- This is AA HL, because of integration by parts and of trigonometric products over a period. Depth comes from showing numerically that the overshoot stays near 9% of the jump as n increases, and explaining why.
- Where marks are lost
- E: coefficient formulae quoted without derivation. B: unclear definitions of the periodic function. A: plots with no labelled axes. C: purely textbook.
- Data
- Calculations are manageable but the Gibbs proof is hard to control; numerical evidence can support it.
The cheapest open box for a fixed volume
Aim. For an open-topped box with a square base and fixed volume, which dimensions minimise the material cost, and how do they change as the base becomes more expensive than the sides?
- AA and AI · SL and HL
- Easy to start
- Your own data
- Seen too often in subject reports
- Rarely listed
My take. Minimising the material of a box or can is named in the subject reports among topics seen too often, and the plain version is a standard exercise. It becomes acceptable only with the general cost parameter and a real package you compare against.
Mathematics, first steps and where marks are lost+
- Mathematics
- Constraint substitution to reduce to one variable, differentiation of x² + k/x type functions, first and second derivative tests, parameter k for the cost ratio, sketching the cost function. Beyond syllabus: showing the optimal height to base ratio depends on the cost ratio only.
- How to start
- Set V = 1000 cm³, write the surface area as A(x) = x² + 4V/x, and find its minimum. Then multiply the base term by a cost ratio c and re-derive. Build two cardboard boxes to test the result.
- SL and HL
- SL solves the single case and one or two cost ratios with a graph and the derivative. HL treats the cost ratio as a general parameter, adds a rectangular base by fixing the ratio of its sides and optimising again, and studies how the solution scales with V.
- Where marks are lost
- E: a textbook exercise if kept at one case. D: no discussion of real packaging limits. C: nothing personal unless a real product is used.
- Data
- Pure algebra and calculus, with optional cardboard measurements.
The goat problem: grazing area with a rope round a barn
Aim. What is the grazing area of an animal on a rope of length L tethered to the wall of a rectangular barn, and how does the tether point maximise it?
- AA and AI · SL and HL
- Easy to start
- Pure maths, no data
- Rarely listed
My take. A classic that moderators know well, but the barn version with case splitting gives real work. Make it your own with a real field or shed dimensions.
Mathematics, first steps and where marks are lost+
- Mathematics
- Area of a sector and circle segments, arc length, intersection of circles solved with trigonometry, optimisation by differentiation to choose the tether position, and a transcendental equation solved numerically for the circular field version. Beyond syllabus: the exact solution of the circular field version, published only in 2020.
- How to start
- Draw a rope of length L tied at the corner of a square barn of side a, split the region into sectors and compute the area in the cases L < a and a < L < 2a.
- SL and HL
- SL does the rectangular barn with sectors and one optimisation. HL adds the circular field, where the intersection area gives an equation with an angle that must be solved numerically, with integration for the lens region.
- Where marks are lost
- E: just applying a sector formula. A: unclear diagrams. C: playful but impersonal. D: no check of the limit cases (L very small or very large).
- Data
- Pure geometry, but the circular case has no closed form and needs a numerical solution.
The safety parabola: boundary of all projectile paths
Aim. For a fixed launch speed, what curve bounds every reachable point, and how can it be derived by two different methods?
- AA · SL and HL
- Easy to start
- Pure maths, no data
- Rarely listed
My take. Elegant and less overdone. Worth choosing if the two derivations are compared and a real context, such as a garden sprinkler, gives it a personal hook.
Mathematics, first steps and where marks are lost+
- Mathematics
- Write the trajectory y = x tan θ − gx²(1 + tan²θ)/(2u²). Treat it as a quadratic in tan θ and set the discriminant to zero to find the boundary. Compare the vertex and focus of the resulting parabola. Show by differentiation that each trajectory touches it. Extend to a launch from a height or up a slope. Beyond syllabus: the envelope condition by differentiating with respect to the parameter θ.
- How to start
- Take the trajectory equation with tan θ as the parameter, find the discriminant condition, and plot a family of trajectories in Desmos with the envelope on top.
- SL and HL
- An SL student can do the discriminant method and the graphs with a clear geometric interpretation. HL depth comes from the second derivation by the envelope condition, the tangency proof and the sloped-ground extension.
- Where marks are lost
- E: presenting only the discriminant trick with no justification of why it gives the envelope. B: unclear notation for parameter versus variable. C: no personal angle; a real scenario such as a water fountain or a sports throw helps.
- Data
- Pure theory with a manageable proof; the challenge is explaining envelopes clearly to a reader.
Volume and surface area of a torus by two methods
Aim. Do the disc/washer method and Pappus's theorem give the same volume and surface area for a torus, and how does a horn or spindle torus change the result?
- AA and AI · HL topic
- Easy to start
- Pure maths, no data
- Seen too often in subject reports
- Rarely listed
My take. Volumes of revolution are named in the subject reports among topics seen too often. Workable if kept to two methods that check each other, and a measurement of a real ring makes it personal.
Mathematics, first steps and where marks are lost+
- Mathematics
- Volume of revolution about the y-axis by washers, integration of √(r² − y²) using the area of a semicircle or a trigonometric substitution, Pappus's theorem as a second method, surface area of revolution (beyond the syllabus), parametric equations of a circle.
- How to start
- Write the circle (x − R)² + y² = r², rotate it about the y-axis using washers, and integrate with respect to y to get 2π²Rr². Then check with a physical torus such as a ring or bagel measured by water displacement.
- SL and HL
- Volumes of revolution are HL in both courses. HL students get the volume by washers, confirm it with Pappus's theorem, add the surface area, and study the case R < r where the shape intersects itself.
- Where marks are lost
- E: the maths reduces to one integral with no comparison of methods. A: unclear diagrams of the rotation. D: no check of the result against a real object.
- Data
- Theory with an optional water displacement check.
Volume of a Decanter: Solids of Revolution Against Water
Aim. How closely does the volume of a real decanter, found by rotating a fitted profile curve, agree with the volume measured by filling it with water?
- AA and AI · HL topic
- Easy to start
- Your own data
- Seen too often in subject reports
- Rarely listed
My take. Volumes of revolution are named in the subject reports among topics seen too often, but this is a solid version if you measure the wall thickness and compare at least three methods. Use an object with a story for you, such as a family bottle.
Mathematics, first steps and where marks are lost+
- Mathematics
- Volume of revolution about the x-axis, curve fitting to measured radii (cubic or trigonometric regression), definite integration, numerical methods such as the trapezium rule and a stack of cylinders or frustums for comparison, percentage error. HL: integration by substitution or parts for a sinusoidal profile, volume rotated about the y-axis.
- How to start
- Photograph your decanter against a ruler and trace its outline, or measure the radius every 1 cm of height. Fit a function to the radii, integrate to get the volume, then measure the true volume with a measuring jug.
- SL and HL
- Volumes of revolution are HL in both courses. HL uses a fitted profile, the volume integral and a comparison with a stack of cylinders or frustums and with the measured volume, with error analysis across several fitted models. An SL student could still compare a stack of cylinders with the measured volume, but the integral itself is HL.
- Where marks are lost
- E: an easy shape fitted with a single function and no comparison of methods. C: shape chosen without personal reason. D: no reflection on the wall thickness that reduces the internal volume. A: photographs poorly scaled.
- Data
- All data come from a simple measurement at home.
Why a parabolic mirror sends light to one point
Aim. For the curve y = x²/(4p), how can the reflection law, applied with tangent gradients, be shown to send every beam travelling parallel to the symmetry line through the single point (0, p), and how does a spherical mirror of similar width compare in the spread of its reflected beams?
- AA and AI · SL and HL
- Easy to start
- Pure maths, no data
- Rarely listed
My take. The classic proof is a textbook exercise, so it is only worth choosing with a twist: a comparison of parabolic and spherical mirrors, with the focusing error as the beam widens, or a real solar cooker or satellite dish with measured dimensions.
Mathematics, first steps and where marks are lost+
- Mathematics
- Differentiation to find the tangent and normal gradient at a general point; angle between two lines using tan of a difference or the scalar product; reflection law as equality of angles with the normal; focus and directrix definition of the parabola; equation of a line and substitution to test a fixed point. HL extension: vector reflection formula r = d − 2(d·n)n, and the spread of reflected rays from a circular mirror. Beyond syllabus: the envelope (caustic) of rays reflected in a circle, a nephroid.
- How to start
- Take y = x²/(4p) with p = 1. Pick the point (2, 1), find the tangent gradient, the normal, and the reflected direction of a vertical ray using the equal angles law. Check by hand that the reflected line passes through (0, 1). Then repeat with a general point (2pt, pt²) and simplify. Plot in Desmos or GeoGebra with several rays.
- SL and HL
- SL: do the general-point algebra with tan of the angle between lines, prove the focus property, and test it numerically on a few rays, then compare with a circle of matching curvature at the vertex. HL: use vector reflection, derive the caustic of the circular mirror as an envelope of lines, and quantify the focusing error (distance of reflected rays from the ideal point) as the beam widens, for a strong evaluation.
- Where marks are lost
- E: stopping at the standard proof found in any textbook, so no real choice of mathematics. C: no personal link, so it reads as copied. D: reflection that only repeats the result instead of judging limits such as real mirrors, ray width and the idealisation of light as rays. A/B: unlabelled diagrams and undefined notation for the angles.
- Data
- Pure theory with a graphing tool for checking, so no data is needed, but the proof alone is too short for 12 to 20 pages unless the circle comparison is added.
Why athletics tracks are not circles
Aim. For a track of fixed 400 m perimeter with straights of at least a given length, how does the maximum enclosed area compare with a circle, and how does the optimal bend radius change with the constraint?
- AA and AI · SL and HL
- Easy to start
- Pure maths, no data
- Rarely listed
My take. Neat and the maths is honest, but the answer without constraints is dull. Its strength is the endpoint reasoning and the comparison with the real standard.
Mathematics, first steps and where marks are lost+
- Mathematics
- Perimeter constraint 2L + 2πr = 400, area A = 2rL + πr², substitution, differentiation, endpoint analysis on a constrained interval, comparison with circle area 400²/4π. Beyond syllabus: showing a stadium shape is the best under a straight length restriction.
- How to start
- Write A(r) after eliminating L, sketch it on the allowed interval and find where it is largest. Then check the real IAAF standard of 36.5 m radius and compare its area.
- SL and HL
- SL optimises with one constraint and comments on the result. HL introduces a required minimum straight length, studies how the optimum moves along the boundary and explains when the constraint is active.
- Where marks are lost
- E: the unconstrained result is trivial (a circle, or a degenerate track). B: unclear about which constraint is binding. D: little link to real track design.
- Data
- Pure theory with real track dimensions available from athletics rules.
Why e: compound interest limit and the derivative of ax
Aim. Why is e the unique base for which the gradient of ax equals ax at every point, and how does this link to the limit of (1 + 1/n)n?
- AA and AI · SL and HL
- Easy to start
- Pure maths, no data
- Rarely listed
My take. A very common topic and risky as a plain description. It only earns marks if it proves the limit converges and explains why the derivative property forces this base.
Mathematics, first steps and where marks are lost+
- Mathematics
- Limit definition of the derivative, numerical limits, binomial expansion for the limit of (1 + 1/n)n, derivative of ax from first principles, inverse function and ln x, Maclaurin series for ex (HL).
- How to start
- Compute the gradient of 2x, 3x and 2.7x at x = 0 numerically by shrinking h, and find the base that gives exactly 1. Then relate this to compounding n times a year.
- SL and HL
- SL students can do the numerical and compound interest route and show the derivative result. HL students prove convergence with the binomial theorem, use Maclaurin series and prove d/dx ln x = 1/x from the inverse.
- Where marks are lost
- E: statements taken from the textbook without proof. C: generic history of e. B: limits written loosely.
- Data
- Pure theory; the challenge is proving the limit exists rather than assuming it.
Ideas were collected from public lists and published exploration titles, merged when they are the same exploration, rewritten from scratch and checked by hand. “On N sites” counts how many public lists carry the same idea.