IB Physics November 2024: what the examiners reported

Final November session on the 2016 guide. Papers were judged fair; calculations and graph work were solid, while many students misread questions and struggled with circular motion forces, binding energy, diffraction, uncertainties and thermodynamic cycles.

By Pietro Meloni, PhD · Summarised from the IB subject report on

Physics HL grade boundaries, November 2024: minimum mark for each grade. Every session
ComponentMax4567
Overall10038485869
Internal assessment2411141720
Paper 1 (multiple choice)4015182125
Paper 29030405161
Paper 34519232731
Physics SL grade boundaries, November 2024: minimum mark for each grade. Every session
ComponentMax4567
Overall10040495869
Internal assessment2411141720
Paper 1 (multiple choice)3013151719
Paper 24617212530
Paper 33516192327

Paper 1

About 90% of schools found the difficulty appropriate. Blanks rose towards the end, especially at SL, and several items exposed misconceptions about forces, interference with phase-shifted sources and fundamental units.

Found difficult

  • kinematics
  • interference
  • SI base units
  • fundamental forces
  • energy sources
  • albedo
  • electromagnetic induction
Paper 1: question by question, in my words.
QTopicHow it wentWhere marks were lost
SL4 / HL4object thrown up then falling (quadratic in time)Most struggleddivided two given values; ignored sign of initial velocityTip: Fix positive direction and include non-zero initial velocity in the equation.
SL6 / HL5elastic potential energy in terms of forceMixedexpected displacement squared explicitlyTip: Substitute F = kx into options to compare forms.
SL12 / HL9cause of temperature rise in compressed gasMost struggledchose a true statement that was not the cause
SL15 / HL11interference from sources out of phaseMost struggledignored source phase differenceTip: Add any phase difference between sources to the path difference effect.
SL24 / HL19beta-plus versus beta-minus decayMixedNothing specific reported.Tip: Proton-rich nuclides emit positrons; neutron-rich ones emit electrons.
SL25 / HL20lowest frequency absorbedMixedNothing specific reported.Tip: Lowest frequency means the smallest energy gap.
SL28 / HL23validating research by independent reviewAnswered wellNothing specific reported.
SL29 / HL24primary fuelsMost struggleddid not class coal as primary
SL30 / HL25albedo from absorbed intensityMost struggledused absorbed intensity as incidentTip: Incident intensity equals absorbed plus reflected.
HL 13reflection of a pulse at a free endMixedthought the reflected pulse inverts
HL 15unit of resistivity in base SI unitsMost struggledNothing specific reported.Tip: Build base units from a known equation such as P = I squared R.
HL 26velocity of an oscillating icebergMixedNothing specific reported.
HL 27width of central diffraction maximumMixedcompared half-width with full width
HL 29diffraction images and wavelengthMost struggledguessing
HL 32potential energy from gravitational potentialAnswered wellNothing specific reported.
HL 34direction of induced current from flux changesMixedNothing specific reported.Tip: Use Lenz's law separately for decreasing and increasing flux.
HL 38diffraction pattern changeMixedguessing
SL 5speed at bottom of a slopeAnswered wellNothing specific reported.
SL 7power from change in kinetic energyMixedomitted the factor one half; used P = Fv with a non-constant speed
SL 13velocity sign in SHMMost struggledassumed velocity has the sign of displacement
SL 18force on a negative chargeMost struggledforce drawn along the fieldTip: A negative charge feels force opposite to the field.
SL 19calculation with area unitsMost struggledmm squared to m squared conversion errorTip: Square the conversion factor when converting areas.
SL 26range of fundamental forcesMost struggledguessingTip: The weak interaction has the shortest range.

What to practise

  • Use MCQs in class to reveal misconceptions.
  • Practise powers of ten and estimation without a calculator.
  • Use elimination, units, sketches and extreme cases.
  • For cause-type questions select the statement that explains the change.
  • Know when data booklet equations apply, e.g. in-phase sources.

Paper 2

Most schools judged it fair; working was clear and power-of-ten slips fewer than usual. Some HL students lost time copying the stem; conceptual parts on circular motion, momentum, binding energy and diffraction were weaker.

Found difficult

  • single-slit diffraction
  • resolution
  • gravitational potential energy
  • I-V characteristics
  • alternating current
  • photoelectric effect
  • circular motion
  • momentum and impulse
  • binding energy

Well prepared

  • motion graphs
  • conservation of energy
  • momentum and impulse
  • radioactive decay
  • wave properties
  • standing waves
  • gas laws
Paper 2: question by question, in my words.
QTopicHow it wentWhere marks were lost
HL 1avelocity-time graphAnswered wellNothing specific reported.
HL 1bdistance from area under graphMixedforced one kinematics equation over the whole motionTip: Use the area under a velocity-time graph for distance.
2ai / SL 1aispeed from energy conservationMixedno extra significant figure in show-that; wrong height difference
2aii / SL 1aiinormal force in a vertical loopMost strugglednormal force assumed upwards; ignored weight; set normal force equal to weightTip: Sketch a free-body diagram for each position in circular motion.
2aiii / SL 1aiiistaying in contact with the loopMost struggledvague statements
2bi / SL 1bicollision speedMixedomitted a mass in momentum equation
2bii / SL 1biirate of change of momentum as forceMixedgave change in momentum instead of force (SL)
2biii / SL 1biiicollision calculationAnswered wellwrong substitution
3a / SL 2aNewton's third lawMixeddid not say which body exerts force on whichTip: State the two bodies and the equal, opposite forces between them.
3b / SL 2bgas calculationAnswered wellNothing specific reported.
3c / SL 2ctwo gas containersAnswered wellNothing specific reported.
4ai / SL 3aitransverse waveAnswered wellsaid propagation is perpendicular to energy transfer
4aii / SL 3aiiacceleration of particles on a waveMixedonly one of two parts stated
4aiii / SL 3aiiiwave calculationAnswered wellNothing specific reported.
4aiv / SL 3aivparticle speed versus wave speedMost struggledreturned the wave speedTip: Particle speed in a wave differs from the wave speed.
4b / SL 3bwave diagramAnswered wellNothing specific reported.
4c / SL 3cwave situationMixedNothing specific reported.
5a / SL 4acomparing resistancesMixedclaimed current passes through X first
5b / SL 4bcircuit reasoningMixedused resistor position relative to cell
HL 5ciresistance from an I-V curveMost struggledtook inverse gradient as resistanceTip: Resistance is V/I at the point, not the gradient.
HL 5ciiresistance calculationMost struggledNothing specific reported.
SL 4ci, 4ciidiscounted (translation error)MixedNothing specific reported.
6ai / SL 5ainuclear terminologyMixedimprecise terminology
6bi / SL 5bibinding energyAnswered wellNothing specific reported.
6bii / SL 5biibinding energy per nucleon comparisonMost struggledno justification; thought more nucleons share less energy
6biii / SL 5biiinuclear calculationAnswered wellNothing specific reported.
HL 6cidecay graph readingMixedmisread the axis scale
HL 6ciifraction of activity remainingMixedgave the activity not the fraction
7a / SL 6aenergy transfers in a wind turbineMixedleft out thermal energy
7b / SL 6bwind power assumptionsMixedNothing specific reported.
7c / SL 6cwind power with two speedsMost struggledcubed the difference of speedsTip: Cube each speed before subtracting.
HL 8aisingle-slit effectsAnswered wellmany left question 8 blank
HL 8aiidiffraction angleMixedwrong angle chosen
HL 8aiiigrating pattern explanationMixedomitted diffraction at each slit
HL 8aivintensity with more slitsAnswered wellNothing specific reported.
HL 8bresolvanceMost struggledcould not interpret the computed RTip: Compare required and available resolvance to decide if lines are resolved.
HL 9asign of gravitational potentialMost struggledNothing specific reported.
HL 9biescape and orbitsMixedNothing specific reported.
HL 9biimaximum height from energyMost struggledignored potential energy at the surfaceTip: Include potential at both radii and give height above surface.
HL 10arole of a transformer coreMixedthought the core conducts current
HL 10btransformerAnswered wellNothing specific reported.
HL 10cia.c. readingAnswered wellNothing specific reported.
HL 10ciifrequency from periodMixedmissed milliseconds
HL 10diprimary and secondary valuesMixedswapped primary and secondary
HL 10diitransformer calculationAnswered wellNothing specific reported.
HL 11afailure of wave model for photoemissionMost struggledrestated stem or gave particle model
HL 11biphotoelectric energyMixedmixed J and eVTip: Use hc in eV nm from the data booklet to keep units consistent.
HL 11biielectron speedMixedNothing specific reported.

What to practise

  • Show working for error carried forward.
  • Know data booklet symbols.
  • Give decimal answers.
  • Sketch free-body diagrams for circular motion.

Paper 3

Last Paper 3 on the 2016 guide; time was ample and options balanced. Graph work was strong, but uncertainties, cyclic processes, telescopes, attenuation and careful reading were weak.

Found difficult

  • significant figures
  • uncertainty propagation
  • measuring g
  • thermodynamic cycles
  • heat engine efficiency
  • spacetime diagrams
  • relativistic energy and momentum
  • resonance
  • optical instruments
  • X-ray attenuation
  • cosmological principle
  • careful reading of the question

Well prepared

  • best-fit lines
  • gradients
  • time dilation
  • rotational dynamics
  • fluid dynamics
  • lenses and ray diagrams
  • Cepheid variables
  • stellar characteristics
  • mass-luminosity relation
  • stellar evolution
Paper 3: question by question, in my words.
QTopicHow it wentWhere marks were lost
1aibest-fit lineAnswered welljoined dots
1aiigradientAnswered wellNothing specific reported.
1aiiiconstant from intercept and gradientMixedNothing specific reported.
2ag from a multi-flash photoMixedused consecutive points; forgot to subtract start positionTip: Use the longest interval to reduce relative uncertainty.
2buncertainty in gMixedignored distance uncertainty; gave percentage only
2cflash duration and blurMost struggledmisread the question
3Galilean and relativistic velocity additionMixedspeeds above c
4clock synchronisation and spacetime diagramMixedpoor synchronisation explanation; proper time misidentified
5muon time dilationMixedused gamma the wrong way
6 (HL)relativistic kinetic energy from a graphMixedNothing specific reported.
7 (HL)light path in different framesAnswered wellNothing specific reported.
8rotational mechanicsAnswered wellstated variable without the direction of change
9agas processesMixedNothing specific reported.
9bgas calculationAnswered wellNothing specific reported.
9cfirst law and efficiencyMixedefficiency given as 100%
9dtheoretical efficiencyMost struggledmissed meaning of theoretical
10fluids and BernoulliMixedovercomplicated Bernoulli; no reference to pressure
11resonanceMost struggledgeneric answer without calculationTip: Explain questions with a given value need a supporting calculation.
12lensesAnswered welldrew converging instead of diverging
13reflecting telescope mountings and raysMost struggledsign errors in the final calculation
14imaging topicAnswered wellNothing specific reported.
15alinear versus mass attenuation coefficientMost struggledNothing specific reported.
15battenuation calculationMixedlogarithm errors
16imaging topicAnswered wellNothing specific reported.
17Cepheids and star clustersMixedopen and globular clusters confused
18stellar radii, masses and Oppenheimer-Volkoff limitAnswered wellNothing specific reported.
19stellar calculations and assumptionsMixedunit conversions; unrealistic numbers
20astrophysics itemMixedNothing specific reported.
21cosmological principle and observationsMost struggledquoted principle without applying it

What to practise

  • Train students to read stems in detail and find the context.
  • Use Section A style questions to prepare for Paper 1B.

Internal assessment

What moderators raised about the scientific investigation this session, criterion by criterion.

  • Personal engagement. interest claimed artificially; all three descriptors needed for full marks
  • Exploration. background copied from textbooks instead of giving only the relevant equation
  • Exploration. key concepts like range versus path or efficiency misunderstood in methodology
  • Analysis. max/min gradient lines drawn from first and last points only, ignoring the rest
  • Analysis. correlation coefficient misused when data have uncertainties; unjustified linear or polynomial fits
  • Evaluation. linear with negative gradient wrongly called inversely proportional; superficial discussion of method
  • Communication. loose terminology (speed/velocity, linear/proportional) and padded reference lists of unused sources

About this summary

After every session the IB sends schools a subject report: how candidates did on each paper and question, and what teachers should work on. This page is my reading of the Physics report for November 2024, in my own words. No text from the report or from the exam questions is reproduced, and it is not endorsed by the International Baccalaureate.

This session was one of the last on the 2014 Physics syllabus (Papers 1, 2 and 3 with options); from May 2025 the papers are 1A, 1B and 2. Session codes: TZ is the time zone variant of the papers. Corrections: pietro@pietromeloni.com.

Frequently asked questions

Which questions were hardest in Physics November 2024?

+
The questions most candidates struggled with were on object thrown up then falling (quadratic in time), cause of temperature rise in compressed gas, interference from sources out of phase and primary fuels. The tables above list every question discussed in the report, paper by paper.

What did candidates find difficult in November 2024?

+
Across the papers the examiners listed kinematics, interference, SI base units, fundamental forces, energy sources, albedo, electromagnetic induction and single-slit diffraction, among others.

What were the grade boundaries for Physics November 2024?

+
Physics HL: a 7 from 69 out of 100 overall in November 2024. Physics SL: a 7 from 69 out of 100 overall in November 2024. The component boundaries are in the table on this page.

Is this the official IB subject report?

+
No. It is my summary of the report the IB issues to schools after each session, rewritten in my own words with a teacher's reading of it. No text from the report or from exam questions is reproduced. Your school's IB coordinator can access the original.

Find out what is costing the marks.

One to one, online, on Google Meet.

Book a first session